symposia

Past Symposia:
P-REX1: Projecting Reclamation in Design



2006 Symposium:
P-REX2: Reclaiming The Future

Date: April 21, 2006
Time: 9:00am - 5:00pm
Location: Harvard University Graduate School of Design, Piper Auditorium

Free and Open to the Public

The Harvard University Graduate School of Design’s Project for Reclamation Excellence (P-REX) will hold a one-day symposium on Friday April 21, 2006. P-REX2: Reclaiming The Future will focus on how reclamation of natural resource extraction sites can be integrated, through design, into the ongoing needs of local and regional communities.

Symposium co-sponsors:
• Department of Landscape Architecture, Center for Technology and Environment, Harvard University Graduate School of Design
• Harvard University Center for the Environment
• US Environmental Protection Agency
• US Office of Surface Mining
• National Mining Association
• Rio Tinto Group and Kennecott
• Tetra Tech, Inc.

Symposium organized by:
Alan Berger, Associate Professor of Landscape Architecture
Alan Berger directs the Project for Reclamation Excellence (P-REX), Harvard University Graduate School of Design



Speakers include:

Edward H. Chu
Acting Director of the Land Revitalization Office at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response.

Lecture Title:
The EPA’s Land Revitalization Program:  From Contamination to Restoration and Redevelopment

Abstract: Clean land is one of our nation's most valuable resources. EPA manages millions acres of contaminated land in the U.S.  EPA's vision is to restore the nation's contaminated land resources and enable America's communities to safely return these properties to beneficial economic, ecological, and societal uses.  Focus on land revitalization can lead to faster and efficient cleanups; bring jobs to communities; expand the local tax base; convert a center of community blight to a driver of community rejuvenation; and expand our available recreational and wildlife areas.  The lecture and paper will focus on how EPA is ensuring that cleanups protect public health, welfare, and the environment so that communities are able to safely return properties to beneficial uses; identifying and addressing unintended barriers to appropriate land reuse; building private-public partnerships to encourage private incentives; and developing and sharing information to promote land revitalization of contaminated properties.



Bob Micsak
Executive Vice President and General Counsel, CBS Outdoor Inc.

Lecture Title:
The Legal Landscape

Abstract: The paper will explore the impacts of various Federal and State reclamation, landuse and environmental laws on mineral exploration, production and related mine closure.  It will also investigate the interaction of these laws and their potential to achieve various land and resource reclamation, conservation and preservation policies.



T. Allan Comp, Ph.D.
Program Analyst, Office of Surface Mining and Director: AMD&ART

Lecture Title:
Crowley Creek: Interdisciplinary Collaboration in Reclamation Planning

Abstract: The first small tributary available for spawning on the Salmon River, Crowley Creek shares a common set of man-made afflictions; environmental, political, economic and social.  This project, directed by Dr. Comp, brought 20 diverse disciplines to this small watershed, first alone and then as a planning group.  The result demonstrates what can happen when the Arts and the Sciences are provided equal standing and equal information in planning the future of a small “natural” place.



William Simon
Animas Watershed Coordinator; also owner of Alpine Environmental Services, focused on stream, wetland, and mined land restoration.

Lecture Title:
Community based reclamation of abandoned mine lands in the Animas Watershed, Colorado

Abstract: The Animas Watershed is one of the most severely impacted watersheds resulting from historic mine practices in the nation.  The small community of San Juan County has aggressively stopped Superfund designation and, using a watershed approach, has developed its own methods to remediate metal and acid impacts for draining mines and mine wastes.  Significant water quality improvements have resulted. Successes, failures, and regulatory barriers will be presented.



Victor Ketellapper, P.E.
USEPA Region 8, Superfund Program, Project Manager

Lecture Title:
Overcoming Financial and Environmental Liability Barriers to Abandon Mine Reclamation at the French Gulch Site

Abstract: While technical solutions to address environmental problems at abandoned mining sites are available, the cleanup of these mines is prevented due to the lack of available resources and environmental liability concerns that prevent good Samaritans from taking action.  This is certainly true at the French Gulch site, a century old metals mining district located just outside of Breckenridge, Colorado, where mine owners and operators either no longer exist or have limited resources, and those wishing to help fix the problem were scared off by laws that would hold them responsible should the cleanup be insufficient or cleanup standards change. This problem was addressed at the French Gulch Site through a unique multiparty settlement that defined environmental liability and raised $6.5 million to address environmental problems, thus, allowing local government to purchase abandoned mines and adjacent properties for open space, outdoor recreations and habitat preservation.



Alan Berger
Associate Professor of Landscape Architecture, GSD
and Case Brown
Research Associate, Harvard University Center for the Environment, P-REX

Lecture Title:
Reclamation Design Case Study: The French Gulch Abandoned Mine Site

Abstract: Building off of P-REX1’s presentation, Representing and Interfacing Data in Designing Post-Mining Scenarios, this lecture will present a broad digital design portfolio of work from the French Gulch Abandoned Mine Site case study undertaken by P-REX in coordination with the United States Environmental Protection Agency, and the Town of Breckenridge, Colorado.



Eric D. Schneider
Author, Hawkwood Institute

Lecture Title:
Thermodynamics, Energy Flow, and Ecosystem Development

Abstract: Ecosystem reclamation is a thermodynamic-biotic process that should develop the energy flow, cycling-recycling , efficiency,  and functions (species?) of natural systems. Stressed ecosystems retreat backwards down a successional gradient. Successful reclamations reverse that process.



Roger G. Kennedy
Director Emeritus, National Museum of American History; Former Director, National Park Service (Clinton)

Lecture Title
Reservation, Restoration, Conservation, Disaster and Land Use in and Around the National Park System

Abstract: I will discuss the history of allocating the national lands to serve political, theoretical, and economic purposes, as against withholding and reservation of land to serve other purposes. Next I will discuss the withdrawal of land from settlement that has followed after political and economic costs were recognized. Then deliberate channeling of migration and land use is set against the consequences of “natural” disasters and political disasters.



Peter K. Haff
Chair, Division of Earth and Ocean Sciences
Nicholas School of the Environment and Earth Sciences, Duke University

Lecture Title:
The Future of Landscape-Humans as Geologic Agents

Abstract: From an environmentalist’s point of view, human impacts on the planet such as atmospheric warming, deforestation, and water pollution, are viewed as insults to a pre-anthropic “natural” state that we disturb at our peril. Notwithstanding the truth of this observation, it is useful to consider the geological point of view: that the history of the earth, and especially the surface of the earth, has comprised a series of radical changes in form and process. The recent emergence of human consciousness and technology—the so-called noosphere—and the accompanying transformation of the pre-existing natural order may represent the next radical phase of earth-system reorganization. This suggests that rather than viewing a National Geographic-like version of nature as a kind of fixed “gold standard”, all deviations from which are in need of correction, one should instead recognize the emergence of a new principle of world organization. In this new world, the anthropic force, with humans as geologic agents, becomes an important new term added to the classic geologic forces of wind, water, ice, and gravity. Together these forces will determine the new equilibrium point of the global “balance of nature”. The key natural characteristic that must be preserved in this rebalanced word is natural capital. Natural capital is the source of natural goods and services such as fresh water, fertile soils, and an equable climate, upon which human civilization depends. A suitable flux of the products of natural capital will remain essential for human well-being even after the world has completed its transition to the Anthropocene—the human- and technology-dominated stage of planetary development. A proto-type Human Impact Index is presented that quantifies the magnitude of human activities or impacts in terms of the corresponding decrement to flows of natural goods and services. To date, the anthropic force has largely been driven by short time-scale dynamics reflecting the quick-to-satisfy imperative characteristic of human beings. However, short-term anthropic activity generates planetary response with threatening long-term consequences, as in the case of atmospheric warming. The necessary flows of natural goods and services are likely to be preserved only if the anthropic force is modified to include a consideration of times that are longer than those that usually factor into economic, political and personal decisions. Landscape design is a discipline that deals with long-term assessment of earth-surface function and that works directly with elements of natural capital such as water, biodiversity, soil, light, and so on. The most important future role for landscape design as an element of the anthropic force will be to protect and restore natural capital.



Jon Cherry, P.E.
Manager of Environment and Governmental Affairs
Kennecott Minerals Company

Lecture Title:
Case Studies of Post-Mine Land Use at Kennecott Mines
 
Abstract:
Mining in the 21st Century requires significant planning, including post-mine land use. Kennecott Minerals, part of the Rio Tinto Group, approaches new mine design with an eye on the future - developing mine plans with an understanding of the post-mine land use as the foundation of the mine plan. The vision of the post mine land use is developed in consultation with the local community.  With the designated post mine land use as the goal, the mine plan can be developed to achieve that vision; with ongoing planning and improvement throughout the mining process. Even in the case of pre-existing operations, this process of focusing on the community's ultimate use of the land, while applying the principals of sustainable development, can be used to review and improve on a successful reclamation and closure plan.  Kennecott Minerals used this approach in the final reclamation and closure of Flambeau Mine in Wisconsin and the Ridgeway Mine in South Carolina. Both are examples of strong community partnerships and responsible mining. Both were recently recognized by the U.S. Bureau of Land Management and awarded the highest honors for reclamation and sustainable development for closed mine sites.




>> Visiting the Design School

>> Mine reclamation the focus of Harvard University Graduate School of Design symposium Miningweek Online